Freddy vs. Jason, Friday the 13th or Scream? Each of these highly successful horror franchises boasts cult followings and is beloved by its fans in their own ways. But which has better box office numbers and a stronger global appeal?
The “best slasher franchise reddit” is a question that has been asked many times. There are many different opinions on the matter, but one thing is for sure- there are some great slasher franchises out there.
Carpenter, John’s Halloween series had a long-lasting influence not just in the 1980s, but also far into the 1990s and into the late 2000s, when the horror genre began to turn away from the slasher subgenre and toward more supernatural films. But John Carpenter’s picture, which spawned a number of other series, such as Scream, has a lasting legacy of many decades of deep effect on horror directors.
Carpenter’s Halloween series is unquestionably superior than the Scream trilogy in terms of narrative quality, general structure, and historical significance. Scream is regarded the slasher series of the 1990s, but Halloween has had a far longer and deeper influence on the genre, which is why it is a superior work than Scream.
The remainder of this text will be separated into three parts. The first two parts will provide you with an overview of the two series, ensuring that you have all of the relevant knowledge. Finally, we’ll provide you with a full study of the two shows in order to decide which is the superior version.
An summary of Halloween
Halloween is a series of slasher films from the United States of America of America. It follows psychopathic medical killer Michael Myers, who escapes from a mental facility after spending fifteen years there for the murder of his elder sister and goes on to commit further atrocities.
Depending on how you look at it, this series either pioneered or redefined the slasher genre. It consists of eleven films, the eleventh of which will be a direct sequel to the first film (1978) and set 40 years later, and will be produced by the original film’s director, John Carpenter.
An summary of Scream
Kevin Williamson is a professional baseball player. is a professional baseball player. is a professional baseball player. and Craven, Wes established the American horror franchise Scream. Scream (1996), Scream 2 (1997), Scream 3 (2000), Scream 4 (2011), and Scream 5 (2011) are the five films that make up the Scream series (2022).
She combines slasher, metafiction, dark humor, and a whodunit with a parody of horror film clichés and their effect on contemporary media and society. Neve Campbell, David Arquette, and Courteney Cox star in the film, which is about the origins of the iconic character of “Ghostface,” played by Roger L. Jackson.
Which horror franchise is better, Halloween or Scream?
We can now offer you our final decision now that we’ve provided you with all of the relevant facts. We didn’t have a hard time deciding since one program offers numerous distinct benefits over the other.
The total number of films
The number of films in a series does not always indicate its quality, but it does indicate that it is popular. Some of the most successful series have had 10 or even more films, which is why we’ve chosen to include it in as well. Let’s count the number of films in the Halloween franchise:
| Film | Release date in the United States | Director(s) | Screenwriter(s) | Producer(s) |
| Halloween | 25th of October, 1978 | John Carpenter | Debra Hill is a well-known actress. and John Carpenter | Debra Hill |
| The sequel to Halloween | 30th of October, 1981 | Rick Rosenthal is a writer who lives in New York City is a writer who lives in New York City | John Carpenter and Debra Hill | John Carpenter and Debra Hill |
| Season of the Witch (The sequel to HalloweenI) | 22nd of October, 1982 | Wallace, Tommy Lee | Wallace, Tommy Lee | Debra Hill and John Carpenter |
| Michael Myers Returns in Halloween 4 | 21st of October, 1988 | Little, Dwight H. | Alan B. McElroy, Dhani Lipsius, Larry Rattner & Benjamin Ruffner, and Dhani Lipsius | Freeman, Paul |
| Michael Myers’ Revenge (Halloween 5) | 13th of October, 1989 | Dominique Othenin-Girard is a French actress. | Shem Bitterman and Michael Jacobs & Dominique Othenin-Girard | Ramsey Thomas is a character in the film Ramsey Thomas |
| Michael Myers’ Curse on Halloween | 29th of September, 1995 | Joe Chappelle is a stand-up comedian. | Farrands, Daniel | Freeman, Paul |
| H20: Halloween 20 Years Later | 5th of August, 1998 | Steve Miner is a writer who lives in New York City | Matt Greenberg and Robert Zappia | Freeman, Paul |
| Resurrection on Halloween | 12th of July, 2002 | Rick Rosenthal | Sean Hood and Larry Brand | Freeman, Paul |
| Halloween | 31st of August 2007 | Rob Zombie is a well-known horror filmmaker. is a well-known horror filmmaker. is a well-known horror filmmaker. is a well-known horror filmmaker. | Rob Zombie | Rob Zombie, Malek Akkad, and Andy Gould |
| The sequel to Halloween | 28th of August, 2009 | Rob Zombie | Rob Zombie | Rob Zombie, Malek Akkad, and Andy Gould |
| Halloween | 19th of October, 2018 | Green, David Gordon | Green, David Gordon, Jeff Fradley, Danny McBride | Bill Block, Malek Akkad, and Jason Blum |
| Halloween Murders | 15th of October, 2021 | Green, David Gordon | David Gordon Green, Scott Teems, and Danny McBride | Bill Block, Malek Akkad, and Jason Blum |
| Halloween has come to an end. | 14th of October, 2022 | David Gordon Green | Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan, Logan | Bill Block, Malek Akkad, and Jason Blum |
Then there’s the Scream franchise:
| Film | Release date in the United States | Director(s) | Screenwriter(s) | Producer(s) |
| Scream | 20th of December, 1996 | Craven, Wes | Kevin Williamson | Cary Woods, Cathy Konrad |
| Scream 2 | 12th of December, 1997 | Craven, Wes | Kevin Williamson | Cathy Craven, Konrad Wes Maddalena Marianne |
| Scream 3 | 4 February 2000 | Craven, Wes | Kruger, Ehren | Cathy Konrad is a writer. Kevin Williamson is a professional baseball player. Maddalena Marianne |
| Scream 4 | 15th of April, 2011 | Wes Craven | Kevin Williamson | Labunka Iya Kevin Williamson is a professional baseball player. Craven, Wes |
| Scream | January 14, 2022 | Tyler Gillett Matt Bettinelli-Olpin | James Vanderbilt is a well-known American businessman. Guy Busick is a character in the film Guy Busick | Neinstein, Paul Sherak, William James Vanderbilt is a well-known American businessman. |
As you can see, Halloween has a total of 12 films, with a 13th on the way, while Scream only has four films, with a fifth on the way. These are Halloween-related points.
Ratings
We opted to compare the scores of the movies from three prominent reviewers – Metacritic, Tomatoes are rotten., and CinemaScore – since ratings are arguably the greatest method to gauge a franchise’s quality. The following is a breakdown of how the Halloween franchise was rated:
| Film | Tomatoes are rotten. | Metacritic | CinemaScore |
| Halloween | 94% of the time (55 reviews) | 87. (21 reviews) | B+ |
| The sequel to Halloween | 32% of the population (35 reviews) | 40. (11 reviews) | B |
| Season of the Witch (Halloween III) | 30% of the total (34 reviews) | 50. (11 reviews) | B |
| Michael Myers Returns in Halloween 4 | 37% of people (24 reviews) | 43. (7 reviews) | B+ |
| Michael Myers’ Revenge (Halloween 5) | 23% of the population (22 reviews) | 28. (10 reviews) | B- |
| Michael Myers’ Curse on Halloween | sixteen percent (32 reviews) | ten (13 reviews) | B+ |
| H20: Halloween 20 Years Later | 62 percent of the population (57 reviews) | 52. (20 reviews) | A |
| Resurrection on Halloween | thirty-one percent (60 reviews) | 19th (17 reviews) | B+ |
| Halloween (2007) | 12% (11 reviews) | 47. (18 reviews) | B- |
| Halloween II | 10% of the total (73 reviews) | 15th (17 reviews) | C- |
| Halloween (2018) | 79% of the population (58 reviews) | 67. (51 reviews) | A |
| Halloween Murders | a third of (160 reviews) | 42. (43 reviews) | B- |
| Halloween has come to an end. | TBA | TBA | TBA |
| Average | 39% | 42 | B+ |
The following is how the Scream films have been rated:
| Film | Rotten Tomatoes | Metacritic | CinemaScore |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scream (1996) | 79% of the population (73 reviews) | 65. (25 reviews) | N/A |
| Scream 2 | Eighty-two percent (77 reviews) | 63. (22 reviews) | B+ |
| Scream 3 | a third of (122 reviews) | 56. (32 reviews) | B |
| Scream 4 | sixty percent (183 reviews) | 52. (32 reviews) | B− |
| Scream (2022) | TBA | TBA | TBA |
| Average | 65% | 59 | B |
The Scream franchise’s average ratings are substantially higher, indicating that the series has maintained a high level of quality throughout its duration. On the other hand, no subsequent film in the series has ever surpassed the box office success of the first Halloween.
Box office receipts
The box office isn’t always a good measure of a film’s quality, but it may be a good sign of its popularity and is definitely useful for comparison. Let’s take a look at how these two brands fared at the box office, beginning with Halloween:
| Film | When will it be released? (United States) | Budget | United States | International | Worldwide |
| Halloween (1978) | 25th of October, 1978 | $325,000 | $47,000,000 | $23,000,000 | $70,000,000 |
| The sequel to Halloween (1981) | 30th of October, 1981 | 2.5 million dollars | $25,533,818 | N/R | $25,533,818 |
| Season of the Witch (Halloween III) | 22nd of October, 1982 | 2.5 million dollars | $14,400,000 | N/R | $14,400,000 |
| Michael Myers Returns in Halloween 4 | 21st of October, 1988 | the sum of the sum of the sum of $5 million | $17,768,757 | N/R | $17,768,757 |
| Michael Myers’ Revenge (Halloween 5) | 13th of October, 1989 | $5 million | $11,642,254 | N/R | $11,642,254 |
| Michael Myers’ Curse on Halloween | 29th of September, 1995 | $5 million | $15,116,634 | N/R | $15,116,634 |
| H20: Halloween 20 Years Later | 5th of August, 1998 | 17 million dollars | $55,041,738 | $20,000,000 | $75,041,738 |
| Resurrection on Halloween | 12th of July, 2002 | 13 million dollars | $30,354,442 | $7,310,413 | $37,664,855 |
| Halloween (2007) | 31st of August 2007 | 15 million dollars | $58,272,029 | $21,977,438 | $80,249,467 |
| The sequel to Halloween (2009) | 28th of August, 2009 | 15 million dollars | $33,392,973 | $6,028,494 | $39,421,467 |
| Halloween (2018) | 19th of October, 2018 | ten million dollars | $159,342,015 | $96,135,353 | $255,477,368 |
| Halloween Murders | 15th of October, 2021 | $20,000.00 | $50,350,000 | $5,540,000 | $55,890,000 |
| Total | $110.3 million in total | $495,564,660 | $179,991,698 | $670,016,358 |
Now it’s your turn, Scream:
| Film | When will it be released? (United States) | Budget | United States | International | Worldwide |
| Scream (1996) | 20th of December, 1996 | $14 million | $103,046,663 | $70,000,000 | $173,046,663 |
| Scream 2 | 12th of December, 1997 | $24 million | $101,363,301 | $71,000,000 | $172,363,301 |
| Scream 3 | 4 February 2000 | $40 million | $89,143,175 | $72,691,101 | $161,834,276 |
| Scream 4 | 15th of April, 2011 | $40 million | $38,180,928 | $58,957,758 | $97,138,686 |
| Total | $118 million | $331,734,067 | $276,824,367 | $608,558,434 |
When comparing the two franchises, the Halloween series has grossed $55,834,696 each film, whereas the Scream franchise has earned $152,139,608 per film. Sure, some of Halloween’s figures will have to be adjusted for inflation, and Halloween Kills will undoubtedly make much more, but the Scream flicks are the clear victors in this area right now.
Impact
The Halloween series has had a massive cultural effect on the horror genre. John Carpenter was a pioneering director who established the tone for all subsequent horror series. Sure, not all of the Halloween films were fantastic, but the series as a whole was one of the finest in the genre’s history.
Scream, on the other hand, was a huge success in the 1990s. Fans adored it, and it is often regarded as the most influential horror series of the 1990s and early 2000s, thus defining the era in terms of (slasher) horror. Its major issue was that, despite decades of immense success, it did little to revolutionize the slasher genre, and that all of the films followed the same formula.
This is why we’ve decided to focus on Halloween.
Verdict
With the data in hand, we can finally say that Halloween is the superior franchise. It wins in terms of both the quantity of films and the cultural influence; in terms of ratings, we used the high rating of the first Halloween film as a justification to award Carpenter’s series the victory.
There are many slasher movies out there, but some are better than others. “top 100 slasher movies” is a list of the top 100 slasher films ever made.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which slasher franchise is the best?
A: The best slasher franchise is Friday the 13th.
Who is the best slasher of all time?
A: John Carpenter is the best slasher of all time.
What is the best horror movie franchise?
A: The Alien franchise is considered to be the best horror movie franchise.
Related Tags
- all slasher franchises
- best slasher movies
- horror franchises
- slasher classics
- most violent slasher films
